No. 22
               
            
            
               11th January 1867
               
               My Lord,
                
            
            
               I have the honor to forward a letter submitted to 
Mr
                  Birch, recently Administering this Government, by the Bishop
               of 
British Columbia for transmission to Your Lordship,
likewise
 likewise
               I transmit the draft of the despatch in which the Bishop's letter
               would have been forwarded by him to Your Lordship had not my
               return to the colony relieved 
Mr Birch of the privilege of
               direct communication with you.  
Mr Birch explains that the
               delay in sending on the Bishop's letter was caused by his having
               to wait for replies to the Circulars he issued to the Stipendiary
               Magistrates respecting the labours of the Church of England in
               their several districts.
               
 
            
            
               2.  As I have become the Medium of Conveyance of these papers,
               it is perhaps convenient that I should say a few words upon them.
               The Bishop accuses My Executive Council of being biased by
               local political feeling.  Possibly an impression rested on their
               minds that his Lordship was not altogether uninfluenced by a
               special local regard for that portion of his Diocese lately
embraced
               embraced within the Civil Government of 
Vancouver Island.
               I hardly know how I shall keep clear of a charge of being under
               a similar impression when I say that the Church of England has made
               more progress and has a
               more numerous body of clergymen on the Island than on the
               Mainland.  Here, beyond the narrow limits of 
New Westminster
               it seems to have little hold on the people.  There, its influence
               pervades such communities as I have visited.
Mr. Mr Birch
  Mr Birch, when he
               wrote, had but to consider the state of the affairs on the
               Mainland.  My present authority extends over the whole Diocese.
               I am in a position to take a wider view and while I admit the
               entire correctness of 
Mr Birch's statements and reluctantly
               concur with the tenor of the Magistrates reports, I gladly
               affirm that great progress has been made by the Church in
               
Victoria and several other portions of 
Vancouver Island.
               
 
            
            
               3.  Without defection to the Church to which I belong
               I say that that of Rome is supreme among our native population
               on the Mainland—and with infinite benefit to the Indians and
               to the White inhabitants of the Territory.  My despatch No. 61
               of 
22nd May 1865, contained a description of the Catholic
               Mission School at St. Mary's on 
the Fraser, where the Indian
               boys acquire the industries of Europe and the simpler branches
               of European education,

 Where they show that they can thrive
               and do well in contact with civilization, and that there is
               no reason why in this Colony, at least, the Native race should
               retreat or perish before the advance of the White Man.  The
               same thing is shewn on a vastly larger scale on the plains
               beyond the 
Cascade range where the Indians own horses and cattle,
               cultivate in many cases their patches of land, speak French
               instead of the Chinook jargon, lead healthy active lives and
               do
not
 not diminish in numbers except when the small pox is among
               them.  Where Whiskey selling can be stopped even the Indians
               of the 
Coast and Lower Fraser are doing well.
               
               4.  That civilization if introduced by Protestant
               Missionaries would have effected equal good I am not permitted
               to doubt.  But the French Catholic priests were first in the
               field and they have succeeded.  Whether it would be now wise of
               the Church of England to interfere in any way with the fields
               already occupied
by
 by that of Rome I am much inclined to doubt.
               There is ample room for Protestant Missionary enterprise along
               the coast, on our Northern Rivers, and even in 
Vancouver Island,
               but I should see with regret in the 
valley of the Fraser, beyond
               
New Westminster, the Indians' belief in the "Bon Dieu" disturbed
               by controversy.
               
               5.  Neither Church has got hold of the Gold Mining Districts.
               Here is a whole scope for
Missionary
 Missionary enterprise.
               
               6.  I do not go the length of one of our most experienced
               Magistrates who seeing with alarm the Mysteries of religion as
               taught to our Indians about to be interrupted by other teachers,
               applies to the Colonial Secretary under date 
26th December 1866,
               
               But do you not think—if it were only possible—that it would
               be wise policy to restrict the religious and doctrinal education
               of the Natives to the Catholics and prohibit by Ordinance
the
 the
               intermeddling of Ministers of other denominations.
               
               
               Minutes by CO staff
               
                
                  
                  Mr Elliot
                     Having watched, with interest, the proceedings of all
                     religious Sects in 
B.C, since its establishment as a
                     Colony, I cannot refrain from saying that the impression
                     on my mind always has been that the zeal & attention of
                     the R.C. priests has been most marked & effective, and
                     have left far behind the Protestant Clergymen.  The reports
                     made by the Magistrates on this occasion confirm this
                     impression, & I think upset the Bishop's complaint to the
                     Archbishop of Canterbury.
                     
 
                  
                  
                   
                  
                  
                     I do not know that I have anything to say—except that
                     I agree with 
Mr Seymour that it is very desirable that
                     missionaries 
shd divide the population among them if
                     possible, rather than quarrel for it.
                     
 
            
            
               Documents enclosed with the main document (not transcribed)
               
                
                  
                  
                     Bishop of Columbia to 
Carnarvon, 
22 October 1866, forwarding
                     letter addressed to the Archbishop of Canterbury.
                     
 
                  
                  
                     Bishop of Columbia to Archbishop of Canterbury, 
20 October 1866,
                     defining the opinion and position of the Church of England in the
                     colony, and disputing certain statements made by 
A.N. Birch, with
                     explanation.
                     
 
                  
                  
                     Memorandum, 
Birch to 
Seymour, 
1 November 1866, forwarding
                     draft despatch to the Secretary of State relative to the position
                     of the Church of England in the colony.
                     
 
                  
                  
                     Birch to 
Carnarvon, no date, forwarding correspondence from the
                     Bishop and commenting at length on their contents.
                     
 
                   
                  
                  
                     Circular, 
D.C. Maunsell, Private Secretary, to Magistrates,
                     
November 1866, asking if Indian tribes of their districts had received
                     religious instruction during the previous few years.
                     
 
                  
                  
                     Eight replies to the circular as noted above:
                     
                     
                     E.H. Saunders, 
Yale District, 
15 November 1866.
                     
                     
H.M. Ball, 
Lytton District, 
1 November 1866.
                     
                     
J.C. Haynes, 
Osoyoos and 
Rock Creek District, 
24 November 1866.
                     
                     
W.R. Spalding, 
Quesnel District, 
9 November 1866.
                     
                     
W.G. Cox, 
Cariboo District, 
8 November 1866.
                     
                     
A.C. Elliot, 
Lillooet District, 
9 November 1866.
                     
                     
C. Brew, 
New Westminster District, 
1 November 1866.
                     
                     
P. O'Reilly, 
Kootenay and 
Columbia District, 
15 December 1866.
                     
                     
                     
 
            
            
               Other documents included in the file
               
               
                
            
            
               
                  People in this document
                  
                        Adderley, C. B.
                  
                        Ball,  Henry Maynard
                  Birch,  Arthur Nonus
                  
                        Blackwood, Arthur Johnstone
                  
                        Brew, Chartres
                  
                        Carnarvon, Earl
                  
                        Cox, William George
                  
                        Elliot, Andrew Charles
                  
                        Elliot, Thomas Frederick
                  
                        Haynes, John Carmichael
                  
                        Maunsell, David Charles
                  O'Reilly, Peter
                  Rogers, Baron Blachford Frederic
                  Sanders, Edward Howard
                  Seymour, Governor Frederick
                  
                        Spalding, Justice of the Peace W. R.
                
               
                  Places in this document
                  British Columbia
                  Cariboo Region
                  Cascade Mountains
                  Fraser River District
                  Kootenay Region
                  Lillooet
                  Lytton
                  New Westminster
                  Oregon Territory, or Columbia District
                  Osoyoos
                  Quesnel
                  Rock Creek
                  Vancouver Island
                  Victoria
                  Yale