No. 4
               
            
            
               14 January 1869
               
               My Lord Duke,
                
            
            
               I have the honor to forward a letter from 
Rear Admiral Hastings
               expressive of his belief that it
is
 is unnecessary that local
               brevet rank should be conferred on the Officer in command of the
               force stationed at 
San Juan.
               
               2.  I have already informed Your Grace that I did not consider
               my note of the 
23rd of November 1868 in the
light
 light of a
               public paper.  It was carelessly written.
               
               3.  As regards the question at issue, it is not one of much
               importance.  
Mr Seward, however in applying through 
Mr
                  Thornton for the indifference of the English Government
to
 to the
               appointment of 
Major Allen seems to have recognized the
               principle that the Officers Commanding the two forces on 
San
                  Juan Island should be of equal rank.
               
               4.  I must venture to adhere to the opinion I expressed as to
               the
propriety
 propriety of this arrangement, but I learn from 
Admiral
                  Hastings that there are difficulties in carrying it out.
               
               I have the honor to be,
               My Lord Duke,
               Your Grace's most obedient
               humble Servant
               
Frederick Seymour
               
               Minutes by CO staff
               
                
                  
                  
                  
                  
                     Put by.
                     
                  
                  
                   
                  
                  
                     I think I 
shd ackn. to shew that 
Ld G. is not going to
                     take any notice of it.
                     
 
            
            
               Documents enclosed with the main document (not transcribed)
               
               
                
            
            
               Other documents included in the file
               
               
                
            
            
               
                  People in this document
                  
                        Allen, Major Harvey Abner
                  
                        Cox,  Charles
                  
                        Grenville, Richard
                  
                        Hastings, Rear Admiral George Fowler
                  
                        Leveson-Gower, Granville George
                  
                        Monsell, William
                  Rogers, Baron Blachford Frederic
                  
                        Sandford, Francis Richard
                  
                        Seward, William Henry
                  Seymour, Governor Frederick
                  
                        Thornton, Edward
                
               
                  Places in this document
                  San Juan Island