No. 44
               
            
            
               23 August 1862
               
            
            
               I have the honor to acknowledge receipt of Your Grace's Despatch N
o
               101 of the 
2nd June last, referring for report copy of letters from
               
Mr E.E. Langford, formerly a resident of 
Vancouver's Island,
               containing complaints against certain of the Officers
connected
 connected with
               my Government; & I have also the honor to acknowledge receipt of Your
               Grace's Despatch N
o 106, of the 
19th June, transmitting, for the
               same purpose, copy of a further letter of complaint from 
Mr Langford
               upon the same subject.
               
               2.  I have in accordance with Your Graces instructions called upon
               the officers concerned for any remarks they may have to offer in
               respect of the allegations of 
Mr Langford, and so soon as I receive
               their replies I will forward them to Your Grace with such report
               thereon as the circumstances of the case may require.  
MrBegbie Begbie
 Begbie,
               the Judge of 
British Columbia, one of the gentlemen inculpated by
               
Mr Langford, is absent on Circuit, and by last Accounts was at
               
Carribou, it may therefore be some time before I can hear from him.
               
               3.  With respect to the latter portion of your Despatch of the 
2nd June, which refers especially to 
Mr Cameron the Chief Justice of
               
Vancouver's Island, I will take an early opportunity of placing
               before Your Grace all the circumstances in connection with the
               appointment of 
MrCameron Cameron
 Cameron.  I may however at present maintain that
               so far as I am aware 
Mr Cameron performs his duties with much
               ability, and his decisions give general satisfaction.  Individually I
               believe him to be much respected throughout the Colony.  The
               allegations of 
Mr Langford in regard to the administration of
               justice in 
Vancouver's Island I have no hesitation in at once
               pronouncing to be unfounded.  I hear for the first time that "the
               proceedings in the Law Courts of the Colony are the theme of
scorn
 scorn
               and derision amongst the Colonists."  Had such a state of things
               existed I must have known it; and I think I should, in such case, long
               ago have put an end to it.  I did indeed once receive a letter of
               complaint against 
Mr Cameron from 
Mr Langford, and in that he
               asserted that "Life and Liberty had been illegally sacrificed and
               jeopardized and the ends of Justice defeated"—but as the allegation
               was merely a general one, and as I found on inquiry that just at that
               time 
Mr Langford had been
very
 very properly committed by 
Mr Cameron
               for a gross contempt of Court, the cause of this letter as well as
               its object was so evident, that—anxious as I may be that no just
               complaint should go unnoticed—I yet felt that in this case it would
               be most inexpedient for me to interfere.
               
               4. 
Mr Langford is the same person who brought the complaint against
               
Mr Pemberton the Colonial Surveyor General, for unjust, partial, and
               improper conduct in respect of the sale of some Land, which complaint
               I forwarded to your Grace in my Despatch
No
 N
o 14 of the 
23rd March 1860. 
Mr Pemberton was fully exonerated from the charge as will be
               seen by the Secretary of State's Despatch N
o 28 of the 
26th July 1860. I would respectfully request your Grace's attention to both
               these Despatches, as serving to give some insight into 
Mr Langford's
               character, and to throw some light upon his present proceedings.
               
               I have the honor to be
               My Lord Duke
               Your Grace's most obedient
               and humble Servant
               
James Douglas