Robert Forbes was a secretary clerk in the War Office. When he left office, he sent
                     multiple letters to 
Newcastle requesting a grant of land on 
Vancouver Island in exchange for the service he had provided. He claimed that it had been promised
                     to him by 
Edward Ellice, and that he had been refused his promised pension and so would take a parcel of
                     land in payment.
1The Colonial Office refused his request, stating that public lands on 
Vancouver Island could only be disposed of by sale 
in accordance with established rules,
 and that free grants were not made 
to any persons whatever.
2