 
                  
                  Mr Elliot
                     This despatch is satisfactory as regards 
Mr Crease. But
                     the question remains whether, adverting to the Governor's
                     observation in 5766—of 
22 April, respecting the inutility of an Attorney General for 
B. Columbia unless he resides in 
V. Couver Island, where there is already an Attorney G. anybody at all 
shd be nominated to that situation in 
B. Columbia. But
                     perhaps the 
Duke of Newcastle may regard this 
desph as
                     sufficiently conclusive as to the necessity of a separate
                     apptment for 
B. Columbia.
                     
 
                  
                  
                  
                  
                  Mr Fortescue
                     If there be any grounds of doubt on filling up this appointment
                     it seems to me that they must be reduced to two.
                     
 
                  
                  
                     First, ought the Attorney General for 
Vancouver Island to be
                     asked to do the duty also for 
British Columbia, giving him perhaps
                     a small extra salary?  I daresay that it would be economical to
                     combine many of the Offices for these two Colonies:  but they have
                     not in point of fact been combined, and have on the contrary
                     advisedly been kept separate, and I do not think, therefore that
                     you could make the Attorney General the single exception.
                     
                     Secondly, is the residence of the officer

 at 
Vancouver Island
                     proof that he cannot be wanted to advise upon the affairs of
                     
British Columbia?  This is the point put by 
Mr Blackwood.  I
                     think that it is not proof, because of course it is the Governor
                     who wants a legal adviser, and who must naturally wish to find him
                     at his side.
                     
                     I anticipate therefore that the appointment will be filled up.
                     In that case the question for the 
Duke of Newcastle will be whether
                     he will bestow it on 
Mr Crease, who is favorably described by the
                     Governor, or whether his Grace desires to send out any one from
                     home.