Confidential
               
            
            
               21st January 1870
               
               My Lord,
                
            
            
               Your Lordship's Confidential Despatch of 
19th May last
               instructed my predecessor to consider carefully and report
               whether it would not be advisable either to reduce the Salaries
               of future holders of Offices under the Crown Salaries
Act
 Act 
1863,
               or to abolish some of those Offices in case a proposal to that
               effect should hereafter be carried in the Council.  This
               Despatch arrived after 
Mr Seymour's death and has hitherto remained
               unanswered.
               
               2.  With regard to the question of reduction of Salary I have no
               hesitation whatever in recording my opinion that estimated by
               the cost at which the ordinary comforts of life may be procured
               in different
places
 places, the Salaries of all Officers in this
               Government, with perhaps the single exception of the Governor,
               are
               
lower than in any Colony with which I am acquainted.  The Colonial
               Secretary, and the Chief Commissioner of Lands and Works receive
               the highest amounts, £800, except the Salaries of the Chief
               Justice, and the Governor.  I know that this sum is not equal
               here, to £400, in any of the Eastern Provinces, nor to much more
               than £500 in most West
Indian
 Indian Governments.  I could not
               recommend that the Salary should be reduced if the Office is
               still considered necessary.
               
               3.  
Dr Helmcken, whose motion in the Legislative Council caused
               Your Lordship's enquiry, is now a Member of the Council of
               Government.  He does not, now at all events, wish to touch the
               emoluments of existing incumbents.  I have explained to him my
               opinion, and also pointed out,
what
 what is probably of more
               importance in its bearing upon the question, that it would be
               purposeless to enter upon any discussion of future provisions,
               while the question of Union with Canada is under consideration;
               because the whole legislative and official organization of the
               Colony must be recast and the expense of a large part of the
               Civil Establishment would be assumed by the Government of the
               Dominion, in the event of
such
 such Union.
               
               4.  The propriety of abolishing any of the Offices which in any
               case are not or would not be required is another question.  The
               Act provides for—The Governor, Chief Justice of the Mainland,
               Colonial Secretary, Attorney General, Chief Commr of Lands &
               Works, Collector of Customs, Chief Inspector of Police, and
               Registrar General.
               
5. 
            
            
               5.  I assume that until the Union of the Colony with the
               Dominion, the office of Governor will be necessary.
               
            
            
               6.  The difficulties which have arisen from the existence of two
               Chief Justices in the Colony have formed already the subject of
               much correspondence with Your Lordship's Department.  I should
               be very glad if it may be rendered possible to abolish one of
               these Offices by provision being made elsewhere for one of the
               existing
Judges
 Judges.
               
               7.  The Colonial Secretary, Attorney General, Chief Commissioner
               of Lands and Works, and Collector of Customs, hold Offices which
               cannot be dispensed with; and the only two about which there can
               be question are those of the Chief Inspector of Police and the
               Registrar General.  These Offices are useless.  But as regards
               the first of these two, the services of the present holder of
               the
appointment
 appointment, 
Mr Brew, have been made available as a
               Magistrate; though the arrangements found convenient for the
               public service have produced the absurd anomaly that he is
               stationed at 
Cariboo and draws the Salary appropriated by annual
               Vote for the Magistrate of that District, while another
               Magistrate at 
New Westminster draws his Salary, provided by the
               Crown Salaries Act for a Chief Inspector of Police who so far as
               I know was never
required.
 required.  Although, however, the Office might
               be abolished the amount of the Salary could not thereby be saved
               as it is now paid and would still be required for the services
               of the Magistrate.
               
               8.  With regard to the last case, that of the Registrar General,
               I am of opinion, from which I believe there is little dissent,
               that it is desirable to consolidate the Registration Ordinances
               and assimilate the systems of
Registry
 Registry in the two Sections of
               the Colony; and that one Office only is required, which should
               be at 
Victoria.  The provisions of the 
Vancouver Island Law
               which is preferable in its general character requires that the
               Registrar should be a barrister, and 
Mr Alston  the present
               Incumbent  is in every way well qualified to discharge the duties
               for the United Colony.  I propose to introduce an Ordinance
               during the next Session and after its passage if Your
Lordship
               Lordship approves of the measure, the Office of Registrar
               General of the Mainland will practically be abolished.
               
               9.  It would be hard upon 
Mr Bushby who at present holds this
               appointment that he should be summarily dismissed from an
               Office which he had a right to regard as protected by Law from
               any change, and I shall therefore endeavour to secure him other
               employment and the continuance of the same
Salary
 Salary until his case
               has been brought under Your Lordship's notice.  But there is no
               doubt, so far as his Office and the Colony are concerned, that
               he is a supernumerary Official.  I wish that I had a suitable
               appointment to offer to him, for I believe that he might be
               recommended with confidence to Your Lordship for almost any
               in this Government both as regards character and capacity; but
               Your Lordship knows the
position
 position of affairs in this Government,
               and except as an additional Stipendiary Magistrate, for whom I
               doubt the willingness of the Legislative Council permanently to
               provide, I should be unable to find employment for 
Mr Bushby.
               Under these circumstances I recommend him to Your Lordship's
               favorable consideration for an appointment in some other
               Government.
               
               I have the honor to be
               My Lord,
               Your most obedient
               humble Servant
               
A. Musgrave
               
               Minutes by CO staff
               
               
               
                
                  
                  
                     Mr Meade
                     I have noted these Papers for your consideration on the
                     occurrence of future Vacancies.
                     
 
                  
                  
                   
            
            
               
                  People in this document
                  
                        Alston, E. Graham
                  
                        Brew, Chartres
                  
                        Bushby, Arthur T.
                  
                        Cox,  Charles
                  
                        Helmcken, John S.
                  
                        Herbert,  Sir Robert George Wyndham
                  
                        Leveson-Gower, Granville George
                  
                        Meade,  Robert Henry
                  
                        Monsell, William
                  
                        Musgrave, Sir Anthony
                  Seymour, Governor Frederick
                
               
                  Places in this document
                  Cariboo Region
                  New Westminster
                  Vancouver Island
                  Victoria