No. 13
               
            
            
               
               
               11th May 1854
               
               My Lord Duke
                
            
            
               I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt, on the 
16th April
               last, of your Grace's Despatch dated 
8th February 1853, transmitting
               copy of a letter from 
Mr James Cooper relative to a resolution moved
               by me at a meeting of the Council of Government of 
Vancouver's Island on
               the 
5th of October 1853,
               
               
               expressive of the opinion of Council as to the impropriety of its
               Members retailing spirituous liquors or following any calling subversive
               of order, or injurious to public morals.
               
 
 
            
            
               According to your Grace's instructions on that head I shall
               acquaint 
Mr Cooper that whenever any representation affecting his
               position in the Council is submitted to your Grace, no decision will be
               pronounced in the case, until any statements or explanations which he
               may desire to offer, are brought before you, and also that your Grace
               wishes it to be understood that in future all parties having
               representations to make must conform to the established rule of Colonial
               correspondence.
               
               It is I presume unnecessary for me to make any remarks on the
               subject of 
Mr Cooper's letter, as I made no representation affecting
               
Mr Cooper's position as a Member of Council,
               
               
                  
                     
                     Was he or was he not, a retail dealer in spirits?
                     
                  
                
               and your Grace will perceive that the motive, which influenced me in
               moving the resolution referred to in his letter, was a desire to promote
               the public good, and to increase the influence and respectability of the
               Council.
               
His Grace The Right 
Honble The Duke of Newcastle
               
               Her Majesty's principal Secretary of State
               
               For the Colonial Department
               Minutes by CO staff
               
                
                  
                  
                     Mr Merivale
                     As no complaint has been preferred by either party against the other I
                     think it 
wd be desirable for the peace of this small community to let
                     the correspondence drop. At the same time I consider it very advisable
                     to uphold 
Mr Cooper, when it is right so to do, as he is almost the
                     only man in 
V. Couver's Island who is independent of the H.B. Co.  &
                     should be encouraged to speak out.
                     
 
                  
                  
                  
                  
                  
                     I own I cannot understand the case.  If the resolution stands on
                     the minutes, it seems to be one "affecting 
Mr Cooper's character as a member of Council."  And considering the great delay which has occurred
                     owing to the incomprehensible detention of all our despatches, it is
                     best probably simply to acknowledge, with the expression of satisfaction
                     that the difference appears to have subsided.
                     
 
                
            
            
               Other documents included in the file
               
                
                  
                  
                     Draft reply, 
Grey to 
Douglas, No. 2, 
1 August 1854, expressing satisfaction that the conflict between 
Douglas and 
Cooper has ended.