No. 42
               
            
            
            
            
               1.  I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your
               Despatch No 4, of the 16th
                  July.
               
               
               
            
            
               2.  In the midst of the varied cares and anxieties that press upon
               me in the present conjuncture, it is no small consolation to learn
from
 from
               your Despatch that Her Majesty's Government feel assured of my zeal in
               the public service, and offer their firm support, in the performance of
               the arduous duties consequent on my present position, and I beg
               leave to say that I feel the value of that support, and deeply
               grateful for the confidence reposed in me.
               
               3.  I observe with satisfaction that Her Majesty's Government
               were engaged in conducting through Parliament, a measure for
               
               the establishment of regular government in the gold
               country,
               
               and were devising means for affording me the
support
               support of a military force.
               
               4.  I have perused your remarks defining the extent of the Powers
               
               conferred on the Governor of 
Vancouver's Island by the Royal Commission
               and observe that you approve of the appointment of a revenue officer, to
               prevent the landing of prohibited articles in 
Fraser's River, and
               instruct me to maintain the principle that the navigation of 
Fraser's
                  River itself, above the mouth, is open to British vessels only, and that
               American or other foreign vessels if admitted to navigate that river
               should be required to take out a license; your instructions on those
points
               points being in strict accordance with our present regulations.
               
               5.  I observe also from your Despatch, that the rights of trade made
               
               over to the Hudson's Bay Company are limited to the trade with the Indian
               Tribes.
               
            
            
               We have always hitherto given a more extended application
               to those rights, believing from the circumstance of the country,
               being inhabited by Indians alone, and from its not being open
               for settlement to white men, that the intention of Parliament
               in granting the License, was to make over
the
 the 
whole trade of the
               
country to the Hudson's Bay Company.
               
               6.  That construction of the rights of the Hudson's Bay Company was
               strengthened by the following passage in His Grace [the Duke] of
               
               
Newcastle's Despatch No 12, of the 
22nd of October
                  1853,
               
               on which the proclamation issued on the 
8th of May last was based.
               
               With regard to the third subject, the traffic of the Americans with the
               Indians, you are of course aware that the Hudson's Bay Company are
               legally entitled to this trade, to the exclusion of all other persons,
               whether
British"
 British or Foreign, you are therefore clearly at liberty to take
               such steps as may have the effect of punishing persons who infringe their
               rights.  But I am of opinion that it would be prudent previously to issue
               a proclamation warning all persons against the consequences of such an
               infringement of the Hudson's Bay Company's rights, and also apprizing
               foreigners that they are precluded from fishing within three miles of the
               shore.
               
               
               7.  We shall however in future act upon your instructions,
               abrogating and
amending
 amending without delay all existing regulations
               repugnant thereto. The proclamation of the 
8th of May was
               
               in fact virtually abrogated by later
               regulations,
               
               
               permitting in the first place, the entrance of boats and vessels under
               sufferance, and afterwards allowing the importation of all kinds of goods
               into 
Fraser's River, on the payment of an ad valorem duty on the
               goods of 10 per cent, as mentioned in the 11
th paragraph of
               my Despatch No 39 of the 
9th of
                  September.
               
               
               8.  The object of that Proclamation which from
the
 the pressure of
               business my despatches have but imperfectly explained to Her Majesty's
               Government, was not solely to protect the interests of the Hudson's Bay
               Company, for in the circumstances of the country, that was a simple
               impossibility, but I sought to establish thereby a legal control, over
               the multitude of foreigners who were entering the country, and who
               notwithstanding our precautions to the contrary, have been with
               difficulty restrained from taking possession of and occupying as
               squatters all the valuable land on 
Fraser's River.  I felt that a step of
               that kind could not be legally carried into effect
in
 in my position as
               Governor of 
Vancouver's Island, but while holding that position and
               representing, at the same time, the Hudson's Bay
               Company
               
               I fancied that important public measure would violate no law, and
               therefore from its evident necessity meet with your approval and support.
               
               9.  The arrangement with the Pacific Mail Steam Ship
               
               Company
               
               of which you disapprove, was never carried into effect; but the other
               foreign vessels employed on 
Fraser's River were likewise bound by the
               same conditions offered to that Company.
Those
 Those regulations have by
               subsequent changes fallen into disuse, in so much as they are connected
               with the privileges or tend to promote the interests of the Hudson's Bay
               Company.
               
               10.  We shall forthwith discontinue the regulation requiring
               the pre-payment of mining licenses and head money on persons going
               to 
Fraser's River, in consequence of your instructions to that
               effect, and in all other respects we shall conform strictly to
               the instructions contained in your Despatch.
               
 
            
            
            
            
            
            
               Minutes by CO staff
               
               
               
               
                  
                  Lord Carnarvon
                     12180 has not reached me with this.  As this is an answer to despatches
                     which were very fully considered, but at a time when I was not present,
                     I do not feel competent to offer any useful advice.