Hamilton to Rogers (Permanent Under-Secretary)
Treasury Chambers
5 June 1862
With reference to your letter of the
25th April 1861, in regard to the funds from which the extra pay issued by
Governor Douglas to the
Royal Marines employed at
San Juan Vancouvers Island is to be
defrayed I am directed by the Lords Commissioners of Her Majestys
Treasury to transmit herewith, for the information of the
Duke of
Newcastle, copy of a letter addressed to the Admiralty on the
26
December 1861, with an extract
from from a letter from the War Department
dated
7 February last, with copies of three Accounts of the
Expenditure of the sums drawn for service connected with the
occupation of
San Juan by a Party of Royal Marines—viz
Bill for £4000 for service -
9 Augt 1859 to 30 Sept 1860
" " £1800 " "
1 Octr to 31 Dec 1860
" " £3000 " "
1 Jany to 31 March 1861
____
6800
Including a balance of £2936-6-4 which it stated to be required
for arrears of Extra Pay.
I am also to transmit copy of a letter of this days date which My
Lord has addressed to the Admiralty.
His Grace will observe that a portion of the Expenditure included in
these Accounts, has been incurred for Civil Service, to the extent of
£491.1.11
the the principal charge being for the salary of a Magistrate
at £250 a year.
Their Lordships wish to be informed whether this Salary and the other
Civil charges have received His Graces approval, and they would
remind His Grace that no provision has been made by Parliament for
any Civil Expenditure connected with the occupation of
San Juan.
My Lords were under the impression until the receipt of these
Accounts that the Expenditure at
San Juan, for which Bills have been
drawn by the Treasurer of
Vancouvers Islandhad had reference only to the
expenses of the Royal Marines.
As it now appears that certain expenses have been incurred
unconnected with Military or Naval Service, My Lords apprehend that
it will be necessary to make special provision, as well to meet the
Civil Expenditure up to the present time, as to cover the expenditure
to be incurred hereafter, if it is considered necessary to continue
the service of the Magistrate, and other Civil Expenses.
Minutes by CO staff
See separate Memo by
Mr Ebden, and Minute.
Mr Elliot
This letter encloses accounts of the expenditure at
S. Juan to the
31st of March 1861 including a civil expenditure of £497.1.11.
The Governors despatch N
o 18 of the
30th of March last encloses
further accounts to the end of
1861 viz £4222.2 Military and Naval
and £104.3.4 Civil. This despatch was ready to be sent to the
Treasury but
Mr Buckland mentioned that a letter was on its way from
the Treasury and thought the despatch had better be delayed till our
answer.
The correspondence enclosed in the Treasury letter shows that, with
the exception of the civil outlay, the expenditure should be divided
between the War Office and the Admiralty, the former taking barracks
and the latter the Royal Marines.
The Treasury propose special provision for civil expenses and ask how
far they have been approved. With the exception of two items
amounting to £21.18.4 for towing and piloting certain United States
vessels, the whole civil expenditure appears to have
been for the
salary and office expenses of the Stipendiary Magistrate from his
appointment in
July 1859 to the abolition of his office in
July last.
He was appointed in pursuance of the policy dictated by this office
on the
S. Juan question, and was continued and removed by the same
authority. He was required I imagine for Imperial purposes and the
Imperial
Govt I suppose should pay for him, but I cannot find any
arrangement about salary. However its amount viz £20.16.8 a month or
£250 a year does not seem excessive and the contingencies do not
appear to have been beyond what must have been necessary.
Mr Fortescue
It seems to me that if you agree-as I do—in
Mr Ebden's remark
that
the Magistrate in
San Juan is a proper subject of Imperial charge,
his Salary must be provided for in any Estimate next year connected
with
B Columbia. The expense appears to have ceased.
Mr Ebden
Will you prepare a draft to the Treasury; apprize them that the
office of Magistrate is abolished, so that there will be no further
Civil expenditure, so far as the
Duke of Newcastle is aware, in
respect of the
Isle of San Juan. State that His Grace would
recommend that the amount now due should be provided for by an item
upon any Estimates which it may be necessary to submit to Parliament
next year in connection with
British Columbia.
In this memo: I assume that there is no other civil expenditure than
about the Magistrate. If I am wrong please let me know.
Other documents included in the file
Rogers to
Hamilton,
14 June 1862, discussing the temporary nature
of the Magistrate and expressing a belief that the sum expensed did
not exceed "what was absolutely necessary."
Minutes by CO staff
This Magistrary was quite a temporary one. It was created solely on
acc
t of the difficulty with the Americans ab
t the ownership of
S. Juan.
Documents enclosed with the main document (not transcribed)
W.H. Stephenson, Treasury, to Secretary of the Admiralty,
26 December
1861, advising that in future the Admiralty would examine the accounts
of expenditure, including extra pay, relative to Seamen and Marines
serving ashore, and that the expense would be charged to Naval Funds.
Extract, War Office to Treasury,
7 February 1862, forwarding copies
of accounts with respect to the marines stationed at
San Juan, and
advising that the only expense chargeable to Army Funds would appear
to be "that for the construction and repair of Barracks."
Hamilton to Secretary to the Admiralty,
3 June 1862, further
discussing the question of statements of account for marines serving
ashore, and enclosing specific information dealing with the
San Juan
situation, with explanation.
People in this document
Blackwood, Arthur Johnstone
Buckland, Edward Coplestone
Douglas, Sir James
Ebden, Richard
Elliot, Thomas Frederick
Fortescue, 1st Baron Carlingford Chichester
Hamilton, George Alexander
Pelham-Clinton, 5th Duke of Newcastle Henry Pelham Fiennes
Rogers, Baron Blachford Frederic
Stephenson, William Henry
Places in this document
British Columbia
San Juan Island
Vancouver Island