13th May 1864
My Lord Duke,
With a view to correct erroneous or exaggerated Reports of a Massacre of fourteen white men which may reach Your Grace through other channels, I deem it my duty to place the facts before you, as it will be impossible for the Governor of British Columbia to communicate them to your Grace by this Mail.
2. The Statements of the Survivors of this sad tragedy, together with the newspaper accounts, which I enclose, and which are substantially correct, leave me little to add.
3. TheManuscript image
3. The party of men who have lost their lives in the manner detailed in these papers, were employed by "Mr Waddington", an enterprising and highly deserving member of this community, in forming a Trail or Road from the Head of "Bute Inlet" to the Cariboo Mines in British Columbia, and had prosecuted this work for a distance of forty miles North of the Head of the Inlet, at which point the Massacre took place.
4. The Tribe or part of the Tribe of Chillcoatens who have committed this atrocity do not exceed sixty in number, and I have every reason to believe and hope that the capture and identification of the culprits will shortly be effected by the prompt and vigorous measures which I feel certain Governor Seymour will adopt. This will be renderedmoreManuscript image more easy by the aid of more powerful and friendly Tribes in their immediate neighbourhood, who are always ready to give up culprits on condition of being rewarded for so doing.
5. The Survivors are now in hospital here and I have transmitted their depositions to Governor Seymour and will not fail to afford him every assistance in my power to vindicate the Law.
6. It is known that the Chillcoaten Tribe are peculiarly jealous of their women and in the absence of any assigned reason for this ferocious proceeding, I would fear that the residence of a number of single white men among the Chillcoatens, and the almost certain results, may be among the causes which have led to the catastrophe.
I have the honor to be
My Lord Duke
Your Graces very obedient
humble Servant
A.E. Kennedy
Minutes by CO staff
Manuscript image
Mr Elliot
Thank Govr Kennedy for forwarding this intelligence which Mr Cardwell has received with great concern.
ABd 28 June
TFE 28/6
A shocking affair.
CF 29
EC 30
Documents enclosed with the main document (not transcribed)
Manuscript image
Copy, Statements made before T.L. Wood, Acting Stipendiary Magistrate for Vancouver Island, 11 May 1864, by Peter A. Peterson, Philip Buckley, Edward Moseley, Alfred Waddington, and Frederick Whymper, relating to a massacre on the Bute Inlet road on the morning of 30 April 1864.
Manuscript image
Newspaper extracts, The British Colonist, 12 May 1864, and The Daily Chronicle, 12 May 1864, reporting the events of the massacre and the statements of the survivors.
Other documents included in the file
Manuscript image
Draft reply, Cardwell to Kennedy, No. 16, 4 July 1864, acknowledging receipt of Kennedy's despatch and enclosures.
Manuscript image
Draft reply, Cardwell to Kennedy, No. 34, 31 August 1864, cautioning Kennedy, in response to the attacks in Bute Inlet road, not to allow any kinds of retaliation "beyond the limits of law" that may result in a "Tribal War."