The group from
Cowichan met
Henley and
Brady who were camping on the island. The groups shared conversation and were fed by
Brady. Later
Stalchum said his throat was sore; the group decided
Brady had tried to poison them. They shot
Brady and
Henley while they were sleeping, seriously injuring both men,
Brady died the next day from his injuries.
Henley fought them off and went to
Victoria to inform authorities of the events. It was widely known that
Thalatson,
Oalitza and
Stalchum were guilty, as they had bragged of their deed.
The HMS
Forward led by Captain
Lascelles captured the men and Thask and took them to Victoria on 5 May. Their trial was conducted in chinook, a language too simple to translate complex
British legal terms and no legal counsel was provided.
Henley testified against the men and all admitted to the crime. The jury declared them all
guilty, but recommended mercy for Thask.
Governor Douglas commuted Thask's sentence to life in prison because she was a woman.