This document contains mentions of Indigenous Peoples. The authors of these documents
often perpetuate a negative perspective of Indigenous Peoples and it is important
to look critically at these mentions. They sometimes use terminology that is now considered
hurtful and offensive. To learn more about modern terminology pertaining to Indigenous
Peoples, Indigenous ways of knowing, and decolonization, please refer to the Glossary of terms.
Rowlandson requests a mineral & agricultural appointment in British Columbia. He provides the CO with his thoughts on the mineral wealth and demographics of the
colony and also offers a warning about the character of United States Agent John Nugent which purportedly features an inveterate and rabid hatred of England.
The minutes regret that there are no positions to be offered but find Rowlandson’s information regarding Nugentvery important.
Enclosed is a draft from Carnarvon to Rowlandson thanking him for the information but advising that there were no appointments open
in BC and a printed volume of testimonials in favour of Rowlandson.
In a former communication dated the 4th May last addressed to the
then Chief Secretary of the Colonies, Lord Stanley, I applied for a
commissn to make a mineral & agricultural survey of New Caledonia,
in reply to which I was informed that it was not probable that Her
Majestys government would cause such a survey to be made.
Since then I have learned that the subject has received more
attention at home than was anticipated on the Pacific coast, and as
it is probable that a governor will be appointed for New Caledonia,
with a permanent staff for the management of its lands and
minerals, I respectfully submit my pretensions to your notice for a
permanent appointment under such an administration.
My qualifications for such an appointment will consist as evidenced
by the accompanying testimonials, in the fact that it would be
probably difficult to find in one individual so much combined
knowledge as would be required to do justice to this very important
subject, in its many varied phases, each requiring some special
proficiency.
I may be permitted here to respectfully express my belief that never
in the course of the world wide colonising tendency of the English
race, has so glorious an opportunity presented itself of converting
a wilderness in a short period of time into a country teeming with
an industrious population. Amongst the advantages natural to New
Caledonia, I deem its auriferous wealth the least, except as an
excitant for inducing a large immigration of industrious labourers.
I look rather to its more permanent sources of prosperity, its
mighty woods & waters oceanic & internal, its unlimited water
power, and extensive inland agricultural lands; accessory to these
great natural advantages is the abundant supply to be readily
obtained of cheap labour from the [Mongol?]
races to perform all the lower kinds of mechanical
labour, who are especially well
adapted to the manipulating mechanical processes employed in
manufacturing textile fabrics.
On the other hand these countries, India, Australia, Central
America, Peru, Chili & probably even Japan may be added to the
list, will supply not only such raw materials as Cotton, Silk,
Wool, Alpaca Wool, Nitrate of Soda, Dyewoods &c but the myriads
peopling these vast regions will be the glad consumers of such
products in the altered forms of cloth, blankets prints &c. This
view of matters will not appear so visionary when I state that a
blanket manufacturer is already in existence in American Oregon,
the wool employed being principally the product of California—the
latter now exports much wool of its own growth to New York. Again
New Caledonia is well adapted to rearing English Sheep of the
Southdown & Leicester breeds in the highest perfection, and its
wild mountain and snow peaked summits would be admirably adapted to the
habits of the gentle and valuable Alpaca. An iron road travelled
by the iron horse will doubtless within a few years make these
facts personally known to the most enterprising British
Captialists, whilst the telegraph lightning flash will unite the
Gulf of Georgia & the Metropolis of England in one community of
interest and sentiment more closely even than her central counties
were a quarter of a century ago.
Great and glorious as the above [rustic?]
prospect may be, a
possibility of its being greatly retarded may arise from any
initial error either in the disposal of its public lands, water
privileges &c. On these points an error small at the outset may be
found to assume in a few years proportions enormously gigantic for
mischief. Having seen much of this in the United States arising
from the operations of specultive land adventurers I think my
experience would be found useful if placed in a responsible
situation connected with the administration of the landed & mineral
interests of New Caledonia.
Again on the many and varied points connected with the eligibility
of sites for towns, ports, roads &c so as to combine the most
perfect amount of sanatary conditions, water supply &c commensurate
with convenience of intercourse & cost; all matters that I have
long and seriously studied & can refer for my character in this
respect to Mr R. Stephenson M.P. & Mr Thomas Hawksley (Government
Engineer on the London Surveying board) testimonials from whom are
forwarded to you. I cannot leave this subject without alluding to
the fact that Victoria or any other port on Vancouvers Island would
be a most erroneous selection for either an entrepot or capital, it
may be the most convenient in many respects for a year or two but
not longer—to describe why would at present be too voluminous.
My qualifications as a chief adviser in the Mineral and
agricultural department, will be best described in the varied
testimonials which I hold, copies of which are forwarded to the
Colonial office. I will however here remark that it does not
consist with fairness that either mineral or agricultural, or water
privileges whether rented or purchased alone or combined, should
have one uniform price according to their value less they be rented
or sold. This is merely thrown out by way of hint. It is on this
point that a general report would be found valuable.
When I commenced this letter it was my intention to have made it a
brief one, and added two or three appendices on various subjects,
but the want of time, as I am now writing within an hour of the
closing of the mail I shall be compelled to make the statement
hereafter in a less formal measure than I purposed, this explanation
will I trust form an apology for any undue appearances of
familiarity or deficiency in style.
The Indians who recently appear to have been troublesome may I
think eventually be induced to employ themselves in occupations
useful to the whites, in such employment as Hoop-making or coopers
&c and on the coast in making Kelp from sea weed. Their extinction
however will be rapid for it is surprising how soon, the appearance
of Indian blood becomes obliterated in the progeny arising from
intercourse with the whites; in the third generation it is almost
imperceptible.
I am now about to name a matter which perhaps it may be thought
somewhat impertinent on my part to do so and out of place—
As a loyal subject of Queen Victoria I cannot however do other that
what Englands greatest Naval and Military heros declared viz the
former that his country expects every man to do & the latter that
each man does from a sense of—duty.
I presume that the colonial office is already informed that the
President of the United States has appointed one John Nugent to be
the United States Agent in New Caledonia, with the object of
protecting the Citizens of the United States & their interests.
The "On Dit" here is that it was simply a place carved out for a
clamorous expectant of official patronage. He was or I might
probably, with truth say he now is the principal manager & editor
of the San Francisco Herald a copy of which is forwarded; as he is
at present in this city, I have scarcely a doubt but the leading
article headed "Topics of the day" is written by him, at all
events it is most certain the article only conveys Nugents
sentiments. To sum up his character concisely I may state that he
is an Irishman with an inveterate and rabid hatred of England &
will doubtless stir up difficulties if he can, unless he thinks his
personal interests will be greatly injured by such conduct.
He was the great friend of Walker the Nicaraguan Fillibuster, and
strenuous advocate of American fillibusterism generally, as also of
all the administration rascality at one time so rampant in this
state which was the means of causing the late Vigilance Committee.
That Nugent would do mischief if he could there cannot exist a
doubt, but the number of Americans that have gone to New Caledonia,
are not so numerous as is supposed, a very large portion of the
immigrations are French, German and Italians, the two first equal in
number [to] the Americans, and would to a man aid the English in any
conflict, it is the American Irish, who are the really dangerous
class as regards disloyalty.
Whilst I do not anticipate any serious disturbance from the
appointment, I considered it only an act of duty to apprise the
Colonial office as to the sort of Agent sent out by the United
States so that his conduct might be carefully watched. It is due
to myself also to state that I have given this information on
public grounds alone. I never exchanged words with him either
verbal or written nor do I know him personally.
Respectfully requesting that my application for an appointment to
the land and mineral department of the administration of New
Caledonia may be favourably considered.
I remain
Right Honourable Sir
Your obedient Servant
Thomas Rowlandson
Mr Rowlandson gives us also information which if we had not
received it previously wd be very important—as to Mr Nugent. I
think he ought to be thanked for this information but there will be
no necessity in doing this by alluding to Mr Nugent by name.
Annex draft.
Documents enclosed with the main document (not transcribed)
Printed volume of testimonials in favour of Thomas Rowlandson,
C.E., F.G.S., Mining and Agricultural Engineer of San Francisco,
dated 1858 (thirteen pages).
Other documents included in the file
Draft, Carnarvon to Rowlandson, 20 October 1858, thanking him
for the information conveyed but advising that there were no
appointments open in British Columbia.
Minutes by CO staff
Lord Carnarvon
I should be disposed to recommend sending to the Foreign
Office—and to the Governor of B. Columbia (to the latter
confidentially) an extract of that portion of Mr Rowlandson's
Letter which gives his opinion of Mr Nugent.