The minutes refrain from comment until Douglas submits his statement.
Enclosed in this document is a letter from Elliot to Shepherd acknowledging receipt of Shepherd’s statement but informing him that Labouchere will reserve for the present the expression of his opinion upon those accounts. Also included is a copy of the HBCStatement of Expenses and Statements of the Vancouver Island Trust Account.
I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of Mr Merivale's
letter of the 30th Ultimo enclosing the copy of a Despatch from the
Governor of Vancouver's Island, and requesting with reference thereto
that a statement of the sums expended in this Country by the Hudson's
Bay Company on account of that Settlement, and which Mr Douglas
states that it is not in his power to furnish, may be prepared and
transmitted to the Colonial Department.
I have accordingly the honour of transmitting the statement
required, completed up to the present time in extension of a previous
account made up for the information of the Governor and Committee to the
31st May 1855.
Also the Vancouver's IslandIsland Trust Account, rendered to the latest
date to which our information extends, shewing the receipts from land,
and from other sources, and the application of the monies to public
uses.
There is one important item of expenditure which has not been
Placed to the Account although it was caused by the Company's occupation
of the Island. I allude to the Steam Ship "Otter."
This vessel has been greatly instrumental in protecting the Colony,
and contributing in numerous ways to the comfort of the inhabitants; at
the same time the Vessel has been employed when not otherwise required,
in carrying Stores &c to other portions of the Company's territory, and
under such circumstances, we have not included her cost and maintenance
in the Account.
Referring to the charge forfor the maintenance of 350 Settlers for one
year, it is proper to explain that it was found necessary to allow these
persons wages from the date of their embarkation on board ship in this
Country, that the voyages average nearly six months; and further, for
the first half year after their arrival on the Island, they were unable
to provide for themselves.
With regard to the value of the Company's "Establishments,
Property, and Effects" on the Island, such as the buildings not included
in the present account, the Wharves and the improvement of land &c; an
account of the cost or value can only be rendered by the Company's
officers at Fort VancouverColumbia River, and the current worth would
probably have to be ascertained by competent valuers on the spot.
Whilst transmitting this Account I beg to observe that severalseveral of
the items are necessarily estimates, but I venture to assure you
that the greatest care has been taken with a view of not enhancing the
amount beyond a fair and just valuation, and we shall be fully prepared
if required, to explain the grounds upon which they have been formed.
I have the honour to be Sir
Your mo: obedient humble Servant
John Shepherd Govr
Mr Ball
I felt the same difficulty that you do, but I think it might be met by
adding to the ackt that Mr L. reserves for the present the
expression of his opinion on the account submitted to him.
Draft, Elliot to Shepherd, 20 October 1856, acknowledging receipt
of the accounts but reserving for the present any expression of opinion
regarding them.
Documents enclosed with the main document (not transcribed)
1. "Statement of Expenses incurred by the Hudson's Bay Company in
promoting the colonization of Vancouvers Island in taking out Settlers,
establishing Farms, searching for Coals &c &c &c," signed by Edward
Roberts, Accountant, Hudson's Bay House, London, 16 September 1856.